There's much talk about the Government's plan to 'Stop the Commercialisation and Sexualisation of Children'. A panel of experts is being brought together by the Advertising Association to oversee this reform, rather than allow legislation to take hold.
None of us wants bureucrats dictating what is and isn't acceptable, but where should the line be drawn?
As advertisers and creatives there are certain things that we understand. Exclusions and time -restrictions on certain commercials, either for their product or their creative execution isn't questioned. But the music industry challenging the need for age restrictions on music videos - is this questionable?
A complainant felt that the Peugot 207 commercial confused her 5 year old boy. Yes, the commercial was edgy and had themes that a child wouldn't understand.
Was it as edgy and adult like as the music videos for Pussycat Dolls/Katy Perry/Rhianna?
Their videos contain the adult themes that their lyrics carry - all of which are played throughout the day on both radio and TV channels alike.
A trip to the shops will fair you no better, where some national, high-street retailers are stocking padded bras for pre-pubescants and t-shirts emblazoned with the slogan 'Future Wag' for three year olds. As I recall a pole-dancing kit for children was available through a major supermarket's online store a few years ago. The problem for me is that these products exist because there is a market for it. Adults are buying them for their children.
The question, I suppose I'm wondering is...can we ask recording artists and retailers to make their products more wholesome? No, artistic license and freedom of speech is paramount to the liberties this country upholds.
Would adding age restrictions on music videos make any difference? Possibly, to the parents who are concerned about their content. But there are parents who will buy their pre-teen children 18+ computer games such as Grand Theft Auto. Would these parents be concerned by their child watching Rhinna's 'S&M' video? Are these the parents that are buying these over-sexualised products for their children? Can we, should we stop them? As grotesque as some people will find this behaviour - we can't regulate parenting. Or good taste.